A Reviewer Asked You to Make Your Materials Open. Now What?

by Steve Haroz, Lewis Chuang, Matthew Kay, and Chat Wacharamanotham

Welcome We are open
Welcome We are open

THE CHECKLIST: What should you provide?

How to share it

What about PCS or Github?

Why are reviewers asking for these materials?

But there are reasons why I can’t!

The general goal is to be as transparent as possible.

I cannot reveal my identity. CHI is double-blind.

My data includes identifiable information about subjects. Or I collected video recordings or transcripts of participants.

My code and materials are messy

Any other questions?

An organization devoted to scientific reporting whose purpose is scientific advancement rather than persuasion